NRL Round 1 Big Questions: Thursday – Saturday

NRL Big Questions Round 1: Thursday - Saturday

To save ourselves from the ‘it’s only Round X’ rhetoric in the early stages of the season, Oscar & Jase are posing a Big Question for every NRL club.

Oscar has already covered the four clubs to tour Las Vegas here and Jase will touch on the Sunday teams + Wests Tigers later in the week.


Thursday

Newcastle Knights

I’m a big Jayden Brailey guy and I’m also not the only one who noticed what Jack Cogger did for Penrith in the 2023 NRL Grand Final.

Newcastle’s ceiling is arguably higher with both on the field but crowbarring them into a spine that finished fifth last year – and who perfectly foiled Kalyn Ponga – isn’t the answer.

Given the quality assembled around it, finding the right mix in the spine could well define Newcastle’s 2024 season. How Cogger fits into the picture from the bench is a big part of that question to begin the year.

Canberra Raiders

Ricky Stuart’s roster is aging and there are a number of next-gen stars tipped to feature in first-grade for Canberra this season.

After previewing a few of those names in the pre-season, I like the look of Ethan Strange at five-eighth and can see Kaeo Weekes and Chevy Stewart playing a role at some point, too.

Whether these fresh faces are ready for the week-to-week grind of the NRL is the question. Xavier Savage and Strange have earned first cracks in Round 1 and there’s a good watch between jumpers #1 – #5 given Seb Kris’ return in Round 2.

Where these rookies fit into this backline and how they handle the step up into first-grade is the question to kick off Canberra’s season.


Friday

New Zealand Warriors

The non-believers say it was a flash in the pan but the Wahs bandwagon continues to gather momentum.

In what was already a stacked roster, New Zealand have since added genuine depth in key positions and profile well to carry their 2023 form into this season.

All the attacking brilliance aside, it was the Warriors third-ranked defence that saw them go deep into last year’s finals series.

Their attack will build into the season but replicating last year’s defensive form will be their focus – and my question – to begin the season.

Cronulla Sharks

As a big Braydon Trindall guy, I’m looking forward to seeing him play regular first-grade this season. He’s got the attacking output to complement Nicho Hynes nicely in the halves but it’s in defence where the questions will be asked.

In fairness to Trindall, that question needs to be asked of Cronulla as a whole. Their left edge was paper-thin at times last year and the spaces around Hynes are becoming a bit of a target, too.

How much Craig Fitzgibbon has improved this Sharks defence over the summer will go a long way to determining their 2024 campaign.

Melbourne Storm

I’d already circled Melbourne’s depth as a potential issue heading into this season so we’re doubling down today.

Both the pack and backline feel an injury or two away from looking very skinny… not something we’ve come to expect from one of the better managed rosters in the NRL.

The left backrow position was my focus in the above article and the surprise Round 1 selection of Joe Chan in the No.11 jersey only adds fuel to the fire.

As a footy fan however, I’ve got my eye on Melbourne’s right edge of Jahrome Hughes, Eli Katoa, Nick Meaney and Will Warbrick. Can they be the Storm’s point of difference in 2024?

Penrith Panthers

Where to from here? The Panthers have evolved and improved steadily over the last three seasons to now be crowned the undisputed champions of the NRL modern era.

What changes (if any) Ivan Cleary makes to this side moving forward is my question; Penrith have been ahead of the curve for years now and we can expect them to set trends again in 2024.

How they navigate the loss of Stephen Crichton could also have major ramifications on Penrith’s season, although history suggests they’ll fill the void well enough.


Saturday

Parramatta Eels

Where to rank this current Parramatta squad is what I’m asking myself over the first few weeks of the regular season.

Even with the emergence of J’maine Hopgood and Will Penisini the Eels roster still feels top heavy and particularly vulnerable during the representative period.

Top tier at their best and frustratingly poor at their worst, we’ll hopefully get a better idea of what to expect from the 2024 Eels in the coming weeks.

Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs

Cameron Ciraldo needs to find his first-choice spine… and quickly.

Too much of the Bulldogs attack currently relies on Matt Burton running down the left edge. Pairing him with Viliame Kikau and Stephen Crichton is an appealing option, but does their attack have a lower ceiling without ‘Critta’ out the back?

Is Drew Hutchison or Toby Sexton the better fit at halfback? Is Jaeman Salmon a starting lock? Who does Reed Mahoney share the hooking role with?

The opening rounds should turn a few of these questions into answers.

Gold Coast Titans

The most intriguing element of the Titans attack this season will be how Jayden Campbell and AJ Brimson are involved from fullback and centre, respectively.

With Campbell and David Fifita – an important part of the Titans attack – both absent for now though, I’m looking elsewhere; Sam Verrills.

On paper he’s a crafty dummy-half who can flourish behind a stacked Gold Coast forward pack. Could this be the year Verrills has some injury luck and puts it all together?

St George-Illawarra Dragons

I’ll be watching the Dragons much more closely than usual this season. I’m cautiously optimistic about what Shane Flanagan can do with this squad, even if we don’t see the results right away.

Where St George have (or can) improve is my question to kick off the year.

Much of the rhetoric will focus on Kyle Flanagan but he’s only one part of the attack. So many of these current Dragons players have upside and it won’t surprise to see a few of them breakout in season 2024.

I want to know who that might be.


Subscribe to our free newsletter and receive exclusive content and premium promo codes:
* indicates required